Foster`s Homemade Ice Cream in Willoughby Hills

Been coming to fosters for 44yrs. The original owners sold it a while back but in the contract of sale the recipe had to stay the same. Still same great creamy Ice cream!

Some of the best ice cream around. CASH ONLY!!!

Good ice cream in a good pool next to it as its neighbor it's on the left

Hidden gem of Lake County & a family favorite! They even have chocolate covered bananas as a dairy free option!

Cash only, poor quality ice cream, and the parking lot is a nightmare.

Most excellent

We really enjoyed the ice cream, portions are very generous.

Just visited yesterday for the first time based on the recommendation of a friend. I never would have known that the shop was there, I don't usually drive down the road they are on. So glad we went. The ice cream was good and it was a good portion size too. I like that it's not a corporate place and has a homey feel. I also was glad to see the rules in place for our current pandemic.

Very nice place with delicious ice cream & Courteous staff

Absolutely delicious! Well worth the price. I don't live in the area, myself, but I'll definitely drop by again if I'm traveling through!

Terrific ice cream and the staff is very polite

First time here!! We just saw a beautiful sunset and wanted to get top it off with a little ice cream. We were headed to a place near our home but didn’t think we would make it by 10pm. I googled ice cream and Fosters homemade ice cream popped up. What do you know? They’re opened until 11pm - Yea for us!! The staff was friendly and patient - it was tough making our selections! Everything tasted great and I’m sure we will stop in again👍🏼😊

Good ice cream. Kinda pricey.

Nice family owned shop w/ homemade ice cream.

Love their black cherry ice cream...yuummmm

The best chocolate almond ice cream you will ever have!! I've been going here for over 50 years and nothing's changed. That's part of the charm!!

I have been going here for over fifty years. Over the years I have brought my wife my two kids and now my grandchild. Any time I am in the area we make it a goal to go here. Wish we now lived closer because they have the best home made ice cream.

The ice cream is great!! But I don't really think it's all homemade... Just saying.

Always great homemade ice cream anytime you visit Fosters. Chocolate Peanut Butter for the win.

Very large selection, fast service, and prices are good. Only downside is that it's a cash only establishment.

Best locally owned ice cream shop in the area. Delicious flavors and treats!

My favorite place to get icecream! I've been coming here since I was a kid and still love it today!

This place has got some awesome homemade ice cream in a little boutique house. Located right on route 6 you can't miss it.

Best homemade ice cream around!! People come from miles and miles to get it!!

Always amazing ice cream and great selection!

Not as fresh as it could be. Ice cream lacking in flavor. We will try again because quarantine could have impacted their ability to provide highest quality.

Great ice cream

Great customer service and a delicious banana split !!

The have absolutely the BEST ice cream! Bring cash, they don't take cards. The flavors are all so freaking good! I can't recommend just one!

Great ice cream

Always fun to visit. Upbeat and friendly staff.

Took my nephews and elder bro after a day of madness...Great service and the young men enjoyed it., (i had none) Perfectly placec as i missed a turn and the detour led us there. Thanks

Awesome experience. Nice homely place for good quality of ice creams. I have tried most of the flavors and its hard to complaint Very affordable and truly worth place to have evening Ice cream. Also, very decent and lovely staff.

Enjoyed a chocolate soda with mint ice cream

Very good food or ice cream

Haven't been here in 30 years and it was just as great as it was then!

Been coming here for years. Good ice cream and a handy location for some of us.

Best ice cream in town!!

Loved the chocolate malted milkshake. Even though they were busy, the lines moved quickly and with a smile and thank you. Check this place out.

People say this place has the best ice cream they have ever had. However I believe Angelo's soft serve ice cream to be far superior to Foster's. You get more for your money at Angelo's.

Was my favorite when i was little and then my kids and today first time for my grandkids!

Ice cream good... I could only sample because the don't take credit cards only cash and checks.

Best ice cream place ever. Friendly staff, nice, old fashioned ice cream parlor.

It is the perfect summer ice cream place and my go to place to get ice cream. It is a bit expensive put it is so so so worth it the selection of ice cream is amazing. They are just the best period.

Fabulous milk shake!

Delicious. Good service. This is a medium pistachio almond in a waffle cone. Lots of almond chunks! Only eating outside, but it was a good summer night for it! Cash or check only, just FYI.

Great icecream and decent prices

Always the best homemade ice cream! Parker house is my go to!

Really tasty and I always support the little guy - just remember to bring cash!

The best!!! Such good creamery!